Preamble
My first game of Impetus was using 25mm figures and U equals
1 inch. My second game was using 1/72nd
scale figures and U equals 1 inch. My
third game was using 15mm figures (my preferred scale, or rather the scale of
the overwhelming majority of my ancient figures and those of the people I
regularly game with) and U equals a piddly 1 centimetre.
In the handling and positioning of troops on the battlefield
it is easy to “bump” them by a cm and hard to tell this has happened. It also means that moves seem to be less
definitive (think bold, meaningful, determined or just clear).
When I looked at the ratio of frontage of the unit to the
distance it could move I became a little concerned. At this point I should state that I have a
previously played a lot of DBA and was always snarky about the variation in a
25mm game of DBA versus a 15mm game (there were moves you could do in 25mm that
couldn’t be done in 15mm, closing the gate being the main one).
On top of that I was just finding U equal to 1cm was
annoyingly fiddly.
What to do?
Unit Frontage to U ratio
For 25mm, with a frontage of 120mm per unit, U equals 1 inch
or 25.4mm, ratio 1:0.212.
For 15mm, with a frontage of 80mm per unit, U equals 1cm or
10mm, ratio 1:0.125.
Applying the same ratio as for 25mm scale to the 15mm scale
gives a value of U equals 17mm.
The Battlefield (1.2.1)
Table Size
A standard sized table is 6 foot by 4 foot (180x120cm), well
at least for FoG it is. The Advanced
Impetus Tournament Rules seem to favour this sized table for 15mm Tournaments
(although 300 and 350 point games can use 120x90cm or 120x120cm) and for 300 point
25mm Tournaments.
Battlefield Size 300 Points
Advised minimum battlefield size for 25mm, 300 points is
180x120cm or 71x47U
Advised minimum battlefield size for 15mm, 300 points is
120x90cm or 120x90U
Battlefield Size 500 Points
Advised minimum battlefield size for 25mm, 500 points is
240x180cm or 94x71U
Advised minimum battlefield size for 15mm, 500 points is
180x120cm or 180x120U
Battlefield Size U Equals 17mm
For 300 points minimum battlefield size of 120x90cm is
71x53U
For 500 points the minimum battlefield size of 180x120cm is
106x71U
Deployment (3.4)
The Impetus rules give this in terms of U with each command
being deployed at least 30U from the centre line and at least 12U from the side
edge except for 300 point 25mm games when the deployment from the centre line
is reduced to 12U.
Tournament Games Deployment
This is changed for tournament games where armies can be
deployed at least 20U from the centre line for a 6x4 table and on a smaller
table 15U from the centre line or 25U from the baseline.
What would that mean for a 15mm game played with U equals
17mm on a 6x4 table? The depth of the
table in U is 71U. With a 20U deployment
from the centreline that would leave just over 15U for the depth of each
armies’ deployment zone.
Unit Depth
The deepest unit is a triple pike block at 9cm (or just over
5U) so that should present no problems with U equals 17mm on a 6x4 table.
Conclusion
So U=17mm for 15mm games should work on a 180x120cm table
with deployment 20U from the centre line.
The proof will be a game.
PS. Making up the ruler was very easy using a Table in Microsoft Word. The settings allow you to specify the cell size in mm. Print, trim, laminate and trim and ruler(s) are ready for use.
Had a bit of spare time over the weekend I see Mark...still contemplating Daves Impetus League as I type.
ReplyDeleteActually this has been something I posted on back in March in the Impetus forum.
Deletehttp://impetus.ativiforum.com/t733-has-anyone-tried-a-different-u-measure-in-15mm#7179
There was no response to my post which I found odd, but so it goes.
Mark B and I discussed it a few times and with this post in my blog is the accumulated thought I have given to the subject. I then reposted it in the Impetus forum. So far I've had one comment which I will repeat in full here. It is by a contributor called Zippee.
"1U = 17mm is a very fiddly measurement or at least will require dedicated measurement sticks.
I think everyone is aware that there is a significant difference between the 15mm and 25mm game.
Table size to game size and scale is also something that is skewed as you point out.
That said I've never had any problem playing with 1U = 1cm and would consider that the default and normal setting not 1U=1" so I reject the premise of your ratio calculation, for me it is the 25mm game that should change, if there was to be a change Smile
However I suspect all this will change with Impetus II where with luck we'll move to a movement system where the U is directly proportional to the base width as it is in Baroque.
Although it has to be said that even in Baroque there is frustratingly little precision in the estimation of deployment space and table size. I'd like that tightened up in Impetus II."